Taxes and charitable giving
Share this article
Historically, many of our clients have claimed an “itemized deduction” on their federal tax return for charitable gifts, resulting in a lower tax bill. However, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 impacted the tax benefits of charitable gifts. Throughout our history, Mesirow has had a strong philanthropic culture, so charitable giving is a wealth planning area in which we are very experienced and eager to help our clients. This article outlines how our clients can integrate charitable giving into their financial plan and still enjoy some of the tax benefits long associated with charitable giving.
Taxpayers have the choice of electing either to (i) use the “standard deduction” (a fixed dollar amount that can be deducted by every taxpayer) or (ii) “itemize" their deductions (the value of a taxpayer's aggregate tax deductions). The percentage of households that use the standard deduction has increased dramatically since the TCJA.
The TCJA sharply limited or eliminated several of the most widely used itemized deductions; for example, capping "state income and local property tax" deductions and eliminating the "2% miscellaneous" deduction. For 2020, the standard deduction is $24,800 for married couples and $12,400 for individuals. As a result, many taxpayers will again find that their aggregate itemized deductions will not exceed the standard deduction.
Here are two strategies to consider:
Strategy 1: Donor Advised Fund
One approach taxpayers can consider is to strategically "lump together" several years’ of charitable donations into a single tax year by making a donation to a Donor Advised Fund (DAF).
A DAF is a vehicle for charitable giving that makes it easy for donors to dedicate funds to support their favorite nonprofit organization. It allows the donor to make a charitable contribution, receive an immediate tax benefit, and then recommend grants from the DAF to the donor's charities over time.
For the years in which the "lumped" contributions are made, it may be more beneficial to itemize the taxpayer's deductions to create tax savings (assuming those deductions exceed the $24,800 standard deduction threshold). In other years, the taxpayer would elect to use the increased standard deduction.
For example, let’s assume that a married couple typically makes annual charitable donations of $12,000. In addition, their only other itemized deductions are state income taxes and local property taxes, which are now limited to a combined maximum deduction of $10,000. Due to these new limitations, their total itemized deductions would be $22,000. Since this is below the $24,800 standard deduction threshold, the taxpayer would elect the standard deduction and would not receive any direct tax benefit from the charitable donations, state income taxes, or local property taxes.
To produce tax savings, the couple could instead combine four years’ worth of donations together and contribute to a DAF. As a result, they would receive an immediate tax deduction for the combined $48,000 donation to the DAF and would have itemized deductions well in excess of the standard deduction amount for that particular year. They could then make $12,000 grants from the DAF to their preferred charities each year for the next four years.
In addition to providing a taxpayer with the opportunity to maximize their tax benefit from these charitable donations, DAFs offer the following benefits:
When you gift appreciated stock to the DAF, you receive a charitable deduction for the full value of the stock and the full value of the stock goes into the DAF. None of the entities (you, the DAF, or the charity) will pay capital gains on the stock's past appreciation
Once the funds are in the DAF, you can invest that money (with the support of your advisor) and any future growth will be tax free
You control your DAF account during your lifetime, with named successors to carry on your legacy
You control which charities the DAF will provide grants to, as well as the amount of the grants made by the DAF to those charities
Strategy 2: IRA Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs)
Charitable-minded investors age 70½ or older can take advantage of qualified charitable distributions (QCDs) where some or all their distribution is donated directly to a charity. In these situations, the amount donated can be used to satisfy the annual required minimum distribution (RMD) requirement, but is excluded from taxable income. This approach is limited to $100,000 per year.
In situations where the taxpayer is not going to itemize their deductions, the QCD strategy will likely be more advantageous than taking the RMD in cash and then contributing to charity (as the standard deduction taxpayer will have to include the
RMD amount as income, but will not benefit from a charitable deduction). In order to order to take advantage of a QCD:
You must be at least 70½ years old
The charity must be a qualified charity
The check must be made payable to the qualified charity
Contributions to a DAF or a private foundation do not count as a QCD
These are just a couple examples to demonstrate how we can partner with you to make minor charitable giving adjustments that will allow you to continue your gifting and still enjoy the tax benefits long associated with charitable giving. Your Mesirow wealth advisor can discuss these and other options with you and your tax advisor to help determine which approaches might work best for you.
“Where Does Tax Reform Take Us?” by Janet Lavaux, Ginger Szala, & Melanie Waddell. Investment Advisor magazine, ThinkAdvisor.com, March 2018
“Timing Tax Savings With Deduction Lumping And Charitable Clumping”. Nerds Eye View Blog, www.kitces.com. January 31, 2018
“Acquisition And Home Equity Mortgage Interest Tax Deductibility After TCJA”. Nerds Eye View Blog, www.kitces.com. January 17, 2018
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/15inintaxreturns.pdf, “SOI Tax Stats – Individual Income Tax Returns Publication 1304 (Complete Report)”, Section 2, Individual Income Tax Returns, 2015
“Rules and Requirements For Doing a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD) From an IRA”. Nerds Eye View Blog, www.kitces.com. June 15, 2016